Chữa bài học sinh IELTS Writing Task 2: Some people say that the government should pay money for large pieces of art, like sculptures for public display in outdoor places.
Thầy Henry (IELTS 8.0) · cập nhật 07/11/2026Đề bài
Some people say that the government should pay money for large pieces of art, like sculptures for public display in outdoor places. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Phân tích đề & dàn ý
Phân tích đề
- Dạng bài: Task 2 – Agree or Disagree (To what extent do you agree or disagree?). Mở bài bằng "Some people believe that…".
- Chú ý: câu hỏi là AI nên trả tiền (chính phủ hay nguồn khác), không phải nghệ thuật công cộng có tốt hay không.
- Từ khoá:
- the government should pay for → public money should be used to fund
- large pieces of art, such as sculptures → large artworks / sculptures and monuments
- displayed in outdoor public places → placed in parks, squares and streets
- Quan điểm chọn: không đồng ý, với 2 lý do khác nhau: (1) ngân sách nên ưu tiên dịch vụ thiết yếu, (2) tư nhân và nhà tài trợ có thể chi trả cho nghệ thuật.
Dàn ý
Mở bài
- Câu 1: paraphrase đề.
- Câu 2: không đồng ý + 2 lý do.
Thân bài 1 – Nhượng bộ và phản biện
- A compelling argument can be made that… (tượng lưu giữ lịch sử, làm đẹp thành phố, thu hút du khách).
- Phản biện: chỉ một số ít tác phẩm trở thành biểu tượng; nhiều tượng tốn kém nhưng ít người để ý, thậm chí bị chê.
Thân bài 2 – Khẳng định
- Câu chủ đề: While…, I firmly contend that … for two main reasons.
- Lý do 1: ngân sách có hạn nên ưu tiên bệnh viện, trường học.
- Lý do 2: doanh nghiệp, nhà tài trợ có thể chi trả (ví dụ: tác phẩm Cloud Gate ở Chicago được tài trợ chủ yếu bằng tiền quyên góp tư nhân).
- Kết đoạn: Not only can…, but…
Kết bài
- In conclusion, although …, I fervently believe that … because …
Mẹo: hai lý do ở thân bài 2 phải là hai ý KHÁC NHAU. Nếu cả hai cùng nói "y tế quan trọng hơn" thì giám khảo sẽ xem như chỉ có một lý do.
Bài mẫu Band 8 · 314 từ
Some people believe that the government should use public money to pay for large artworks, such as sculptures, in outdoor public places. Despite some arguments in favour of this view, I strongly believe that such projects should not be funded by the government because public money is needed for more essential services and private organisations can pay for public art instead.
A compelling argument can be made that public sculptures bring cultural and economic benefits. Since many statues honour historical events and national heroes, they can help people remember their history and feel proud of their country. In addition, some famous sculptures become landmarks that attract tourists. Nonetheless, this line of reasoning is flawed because it overlooks the fact that only a small number of artworks become famous attractions. Many expensive sculptures receive little attention from the public, and some are even criticised as a waste of taxpayers' money. Therefore, the benefits of public art are not guaranteed.
While public art can make cities more attractive, I firmly contend that the government should not pay for it for two main reasons. Firstly, government budgets are limited, so essential services should come first. For example, the money spent on one large sculpture could be used to buy medical equipment for a local hospital or repair old school buildings, which directly improves people's lives. More importantly, public art can be funded by private sources. For instance, Cloud Gate, a famous sculpture in Chicago, was paid for mainly by private donations, yet it is free for everyone to enjoy. Thus, not only can this approach save public money for essential needs, but it can also allow cities to have beautiful artworks.
In conclusion, although public sculptures have some benefits, I fervently believe that the government should not pay for them because public money should be spent on essential services and private organisations can fund public art instead.
Từ vựng hay trong bài
- public money / taxpayers' money – ngân sách công / tiền thuế của người dân
- large artworks / sculptures – tác phẩm nghệ thuật lớn / tượng điêu khắc
- outdoor public places – không gian công cộng ngoài trời
- honour historical events and national heroes – tôn vinh sự kiện lịch sử và anh hùng dân tộc
- become landmarks – trở thành biểu tượng của địa phương
- receive little attention – ít được chú ý
- be criticised as a waste of – bị chỉ trích là lãng phí
- government budgets are limited – ngân sách chính phủ có hạn
- essential services – dịch vụ thiết yếu
- medical equipment – trang thiết bị y tế
- private donations / private sources – tiền quyên góp tư nhân / nguồn tư nhân
- be free for everyone to enjoy – ai cũng được thưởng thức miễn phí
Nhận xét & chữa bài theo 4 tiêu chí IELTS
Bài của học viên (band ước lượng 7.0)
It is indisputable that the impacts of public artworks have garnered widespread attention in recent years Some people believe that the government should pay for large artworks, such as sculptures, in outdoor public places. Despite some arguments in favor of these pieces of art this view, I strongly believe that public money would be better spent on more pressing needs and that private organizations can fund public art instead.
A compelling argument can be made that spending on statues in shared areas can reflect traditions and collective memory. For example, people feel a stronger connection to historical events and figures through sculptures, so they pay tribute to the contributions of previous generations. suggesting that subsidizing public display is necessary Nonetheless, this line of reasoning is flawed because when with a great number of people receiving receive inadequate medical treatment services and suffering suffer from poverty, funding for displaying sculptural works can be perceived as a luxury. Thus, budget allocation for sculptures in public spaces falls short of supporting a broader segment of society, making it less cost-effective may not be the best use of public money.
In spite of some minor benefits, I firmly believe that other societal sectors, such as healthcare, should take precedence over building sculptures the government should not pay for public sculptures for myriad key two main reasons. Firstly, medical treatment services can bring about immediate and tangible benefits for the public, while not everyone has the chance to see these public artworks. Additionally, adequate expenditure on healthcare can ensure timely surgeries for patients, whereas funding for artworks does not directly save one's life essential services such as healthcare should come first. For example, the money spent on one large sculpture could be used to buy medical equipment that helps save patients' lives. More importantly, public art can be funded by private sources. For instance, Cloud Gate, a famous sculpture in Chicago, was paid for mainly by private donations. Thus, the functions of healthcare are superior to those of shared sculptures in this context not only can this approach save public money for essential needs, but it can also allow cities to have beautiful artworks.
In conclusion, while there are a multitude of reasons why masterpieces should be publicly funded in open spaces public sculptures have some benefits, I fervently believe that expenditure on these artistic landmarks is not a worthwhile use of public money because essential services should come first and private sources can pay for them instead.
Nhận xét của thầy
- Điểm mạnh: thân bài 1 nhượng bộ đúng ý (tượng lưu giữ ký ức tập thể); phản biện bằng ý "ngân sách nên dùng cho việc cấp bách hơn" trúng đề; chính tả Mỹ dùng nhất quán.
- Hai lý do ở thân bài 2 thực chất là một (lỗi chính): cả hai đều nói "y tế quan trọng hơn", lặp lại phần phản biện ở thân bài 1. Lý do 1 còn tự mâu thuẫn: tượng đặt ngoài trời là thứ ai cũng xem được miễn phí. Lý do thứ hai nên là ý khác hẳn (tư nhân, nhà tài trợ có thể chi trả).
- Thân bài 2 không có ví dụ cụ thể.
- Mở bài "garnered widespread attention" không paraphrase đề; thesis không nêu lý do.
- Lỗi lặp lại: "suggesting that" dùng sai; "myriad key reasons" nhưng chỉ có 2; "with a great number of people receiving… and suffering…" → "when a great number of people receive… and suffer…".
- Kết bài tự làm yếu quan điểm: "a multitude of reasons why masterpieces should be publicly funded"; câu kết thân bài 2 "the functions of healthcare are superior to those of shared sculptures" gượng.
Chữa bài Writing