IELTS with HenryChữa bài Writing
Khoá học Online
IELTS Writing Task 2Positive – Negative developmentBand 8

Chữa bài học sinh IELTS Writing Task 2: In many countries today, people in cities either live alone or in small family units, rather than in large, extended family groups.

Thầy Henry (IELTS 8.0) · cập nhật 07/11/2026

Đề bài

In many countries today, people in cities either live alone or in small family units, rather than in large, extended family groups. Is this a positive or negative trend?

Phân tích đề & dàn ý

Phân tích đề

  • Dạng bài: Task 2 – Positive or Negative trend. Dùng khung: "There has been much debate about whether…" / "In my opinion, this is a positive/negative trend, since…" / kết bài "In conclusion, I believe that… is a beneficial/harmful trend, since… Unless…".
  • Chú ý phạm vi: so sánh "extended family" (nhiều thế hệ sống chung: ông bà, cha mẹ, cô chú) với "small family units / living alone". Đề KHÔNG nói về số con trong gia đình.
  • Từ khoá:
  • live alone or in small family units → live on their own or in nuclear families
  • large, extended family groups → extended families / multi-generational households
  • a positive or negative trend → a beneficial or harmful development
  • Quan điểm chọn: tiêu cực, vì (1) người già bị cô lập, (2) bố mẹ đi làm mất sự hỗ trợ trông con từ ông bà.

Dàn ý

Mở bài

  • There has been much debate about whether…
  • In my opinion, this is a negative trend, since… (2 lý do).

Thân bài 1 – Mặt tích cực

  • It is understandable why some people regard this trend as positive.
  • One clear advantage is… (riêng tư, tự lập).
  • Another benefit is… (dễ chuyển nơi ở theo công việc).

Thân bài 2 – Mặt tiêu cực (mạnh hơn)

  • However, I believe there are stronger drawbacks to this trend.
  • One major disadvantage is… (người già sống một mình, không ai giúp khi khẩn cấp; ví dụ Nhật Bản).
  • Additionally… (không có ông bà trông cháu → tốn tiền gửi trẻ).

Kết bài

  • In conclusion, I believe that… is a negative trend, since… Unless…, …

Mẹo: dùng "may", "can", "many" khi nói về tác động tâm lý. "Living alone may make people feel lonely" an toàn hơn nhiều so với "living alone causes mental illnesses".

Bài mẫu Band 8 · 297 từ

There has been much debate about whether the shift from extended families to living alone or in nuclear families in cities is a positive development. In my opinion, this is a negative trend, since it leaves many older people isolated and deprives working parents of valuable support with childcare.

It is understandable why some people regard this trend as positive. One clear advantage is that living alone or in a small family gives people more privacy and independence. Adults can decide how to spend their money and time without interference from relatives. Another benefit is that small households can move more easily. For example, a young couple without other relatives living with them can relocate to another city for a better job without having to consider the needs of many family members.

However, I believe there are stronger drawbacks to this trend. One major disadvantage is that many elderly people end up living on their own. Without children or grandchildren nearby, they may feel lonely and have no one to help them in an emergency, such as a fall or a sudden illness. In Japan, for example, the number of older people living alone has risen sharply, and some even pass away unnoticed in their homes. Additionally, working parents in small families lose the support of grandparents. In extended families, grandparents can look after young children while parents are at work, whereas nuclear families often have to pay for expensive childcare, which puts pressure on household budgets.

In conclusion, I believe that the move away from extended families is a negative trend, since it leaves older people without care and makes life harder for working parents. Unless governments provide more support for the elderly and young families, this trend may weaken family bonds in the long term.

Từ vựng hay trong bài

  • extended families – gia đình nhiều thế hệ
  • nuclear families – gia đình hạt nhân (bố mẹ và con cái)
  • isolated – bị cô lập
  • valuable support with childcare – sự hỗ trợ quý giá trong việc trông con
  • more privacy and independence – nhiều sự riêng tư và tự lập hơn
  • interference from relatives – sự can thiệp từ họ hàng
  • relocate to another city – chuyển đến thành phố khác sinh sống
  • living on their own – sống một mình
  • feel lonely – cảm thấy cô đơn
  • in an emergency – trong trường hợp khẩn cấp
  • pass away unnoticed – qua đời mà không ai hay biết
  • pay for expensive childcare – trả tiền dịch vụ trông trẻ đắt đỏ
  • puts pressure on household budgets – gây áp lực lên ngân sách gia đình
  • provide more support for – hỗ trợ nhiều hơn cho
  • weaken family bonds – làm suy yếu sự gắn kết gia đình

Nhận xét & chữa bài theo 4 tiêu chí IELTS

Bài của học viên (band ước lượng 6.5)

A contentious debate surrounds the optimal approach to residing in urban areas There has been much debate about whether the shift from extended families to living alone or in small families in cities is a positive development. Despite some benefits of living independently or in smaller families, I strongly believe that the advantages are outweighed by its drawbacks this is a negative trend because it leaves older people isolated and deprives working parents of support with childcare.

A compelling argument can be made that opting for downsized families or a solitary lifestyle living alone or in a small family helps city dwellers reduce financial burdens due to the increasing costs of living in metropolises big cities. Extended families have to pay more expenses in terms of food, housing and education for children, suggesting that a feasible solution to cutting these expenses is living alone or having fewer kids For example, they can rent a smaller flat and spend less on food and bills. Nonetheless, this line of reasoning is flawed because it overlooks the financial contributions of other members, such as older people. They can support their families financially through pensions or other sources of income, which minimizes can reduce financial pressure effectively. Therefore, the positive impacts of this shift in lifestyle are seemingly limited as opposed to bigger families living in an extended family is not necessarily more expensive.

However, I firmly contend that choosing solitude to live alone or in smaller households brings about more disadvantages for two main reasons. On the one hand Firstly, living in small family units has a negative impact on children's social development. For instance, through sharing and playing with siblings, kids develop emotional control and empathy, while kids raised in single-child households can be perceived as self-centered or selfish due to receiving excessive attention working parents in small families lose the support of grandparents. For instance, in extended families, grandparents can look after young children while parents are at work, whereas nuclear families often have to pay for expensive childcare. On the other hand More importantly, people who live alone are prone to psychological illnesses may feel lonely, especially older people. They have to deal with personal and professional challenges on their own without emotional support, which leads to can lead to anxiety and stress and leave them with no one to help in an emergency.

In conclusion, in spite of minor merits of dwindling families some benefits of small families in urban areas, I fervently believe that the demerits of this phenomenon are superior drawbacks of this trend outweigh its benefits as they impede children's social development and cause mental illnesses it deprives working parents of childcare support and leaves many people, especially the elderly, lonely.

Nhận xét của thầy

  • Điểm mạnh: quan điểm rõ ràng (xu hướng tiêu cực); ý người sống một mình thiếu chỗ dựa tinh thần hợp lý; phản biện bằng việc người lớn tuổi đóng góp tài chính (lương hưu) có ý tưởng.
  • Hiểu lệch đề: đề so sánh gia đình nhiều thế hệ với gia đình nhỏ hoặc sống một mình, nhưng bài chuyển sang "có ít con" và "con một". Gia đình nhỏ vẫn có thể có nhiều con, nên lý do "không có anh chị em" không trả lời đúng câu hỏi.
  • Chép ý và cụm từ từ bài trông trẻ: "develop emotional control and empathy", "self-centered… due to receiving excessive attention" dùng lại gần nguyên văn, và vẫn mang tính quy chụp.
  • Khẳng định quá mạnh: "prone to psychological illnesses", "cause mental illnesses", "minimizes financial pressure effectively".
  • Dùng sai từ nối: "On the one hand… On the other hand" dùng cho hai mặt đối lập → "Firstly… More importantly…". Chưa dùng khung dạng Positive or Negative ("There has been much debate about whether…", "In conclusion, I believe that… is a negative trend, since… Unless…").
  • Lỗi lặp lại: mở bài "the optimal approach to residing in urban areas" không paraphrase đề, thesis không nêu lý do; "suggesting that" dùng sai; "the demerits… are superior" sai từ; "this phenomenon".

Bài cùng dạng

📝 Task 2Positive – Negative developmentBand 8.0 Bài mẫu IELTS Writing Task 2: Advertising is becoming more and more common in everyday life.Advertising is becoming more and more common in everyday life. Is this a positive or negative development? 📝 Task 2Discuss both viewsBand 8.0 Bài mẫu đề 14/11 IELTS Writing Task 2 Discuss both views: Biến đổi khí hậu gây hại hay tạo cơ hội cho doanh nghiệp?Some people think that climate change could have a negative effect on business. Other people think that climate change could create more business opportunities. Discuss both views and give your own op… 📝 Task 2Opinion (Agree / Disagree)Band 8.0 Bài mẫu đề thi 14/11 IELTS Writing Task 2 Agree or Disagree: Thu hẹp khoảng cách giàu nghèo có phải cách tốt nhất để xã hội hạnh phúc hơn?Many people believe that the best way to produce a happier society is to ensure that there is only a small difference between the earnings of its richest and poorest members. To what extent do you agr… 📝 Task 2Reason and SolutionBand 8.0 Bài mẫu đề 12/11/2026 IELTS Writing Task 2 Cause and Solution: Vì sao người cao tuổi ít tập thể dục và cách khuyến khích họ vận độngDoctors recommend that older people exercise regularly. However, many older people do not exercise enough. What could be the reasons for this? What can be done to encourage them to do physical activit… 📝 Task 2Opinion (Agree / Disagree)Band 8.0 Chữa bài học sinh IELTS Writing Task 2: Government should invest on teaching science subjects rather than other subjects for the country to develop and progress.Government should invest on teaching science subjects rather than other subjects for the country to develop and progress. To what extend do you agree or not agree? 📝 Task 2Opinion (Agree / Disagree)Band 8.0 Chữa bài học sinh IELTS Writing Task 2: Full-time university students spend a lot of time studying.Full-time university students spend a lot of time studying. Some say they should do other activities too. To what extent do you agree or disagree?